Page 1 of 1

def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 2:48 pm
by ivanhandler
I used to be able to print with my Max V3 for 30+ hours. Now after about 2 hours I get the def on the temperature display and the print is gone. I have also noticed that the nozzle and bed temps appear to be varying much more than normal. This has started to degenerate within the last 3 or 4 days.
Any ideas for what is causing this? What can I do to fix it? Thanks much for any insight.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 4:02 pm
by IMBoring25
If the temperatures are jumping abruptly up and down you have a thermistor wiring problem. If it's going smoothly, check wiring, drive voltage, and PID.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 7:57 pm
by ivanhandler
Thanks. How do I check the drive voltage and PID? I bought the Max V3 pre-assembled. Where is the best source of information on how to do this?

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Mon Oct 23, 2017 10:57 pm
by ivanhandler
OK, figured out how to autotune pid. Did it for both hot end and bed. Things look really good right now.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 8:18 pm
by ivanhandler
I spoke too soon. It went def again after about 7 hours. Not sure what wiring to check out. Any hints would be appreciated.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Tue Oct 24, 2017 9:23 pm
by Xenocrates
So, the wiring most likely to have been damaged is the hotend wiring. I would do a resistance reading on each wire for the thermistor and heater cartridge, and see if the resistance changes much as you move the hotend around the build area. if you find one that does that, replace it. Once you've gone over all of them, try it again.

Another source of issues is that in the northern parts of the world, temperatures are dropping, so if there are drafts from outside the house, or just drafts in generally, they may be getting cold enough to actually overwhelm the temperature management, so a quick fix would be a blanket, dropcloth, or cardboard box. Longer term, you may want an enclosure. There's plenty of topics on here about them, so check those out for more info.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Wed Oct 25, 2017 5:34 pm
by ivanhandler
So it turns out it is in the thermistor on the bed (nozzle may be an issue too, I will keep a lookout for that as well). I went over all the wiring, reseated everything I could. When I got to the bed I noticed that the kapton tape over the thermistor in the center of the bed was loose. I put another strip of tape over it and that seemed to stabilize everything. Got a def again after an 11 hour print and was about to panic. Went to the bed pulled off the old tape and put a couple of new ones down and noticed that the thermistor was way up above the bed. I pushed it down and things looked good for a second. When I turned on the printer the bed showed 366 degrees and then everything went def. After a few times of going back and repositioning the thermistor things appear normal again. Doing some more prints and crossing my fingers.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Thu Oct 26, 2017 12:16 am
by IMBoring25
That's useful info. High temperature is low resistance. You're probably looking for someplace that's not insulated properly and shorting out. Could be the thermistor itself or anywhere the two wires to the thermistor could touch each other.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Thu Oct 26, 2017 8:21 pm
by ivanhandler
This has become really weird. I am getting the def after about 30 minutes. What is weird is that after I press the reset button to stop the print so the heaters turn off, it then reports the correct temperature again. Of course, the print is ruined at that point, luckily it didn't get very far. I am assuming something is wrong with the thermistor and will order a new one. Other insight will be greatly appreciated.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 12:02 am
by IMBoring25
The tricky thing about intermittent electrical issues is that they're intermittent. You get something making contact that's not supposed to make contact (or something not making contact that is supposed to make contact), but only when just the wrong vibration happens in the machine. Consistent issues are easier to troubleshoot. Obvious candidates here would be whether the PTFE insulation on the thermistor legs goes up far enough to prevent the thermistor legs shorting each other out next to the bead and whether the joints between the thermistor legs and the wires are properly and robustly insulated.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 8:14 am
by geneb
Make sure you've installed the thermistor as shown here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6yl74TzBxY - it's very important that the thermistor legs are covered with PTFE tubing.

g.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Fri Oct 27, 2017 1:57 pm
by ivanhandler
Thanks. I was careful with the PTFE tubing. I noticed several things that may or may not be relevant. First the temperature stops to dip and won't go back up just before the def appears. Secondly I noticed that the solder for one of the white wires that connects to the mainboard didn't look too shiny. I fixed that. If that doesn't work I will review the ptfe tubing on the thermistor. If that doesn't work, I just ordered 2 new thermistors (just in case). One of these days I will get to the bottom of this.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Sat Oct 28, 2017 7:43 pm
by ivanhandler
So I finally figured it out. One of the pads for the thermistor separated from the bed. The Kapton tape held it down, but not that well. I have tried to solder it back, but the solder won't hold since the pad is gone. Anyway, I ordered a new bed. That should do the trick.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 3:01 pm
by thingismith
Did that work for you? I had this problem when I upgraded my v2 with an accelerometer and whip. Turns out that while printing the connection between the accelerometer and the whip would wiggle loose during sharp movements. Not enough to free the whip from the accelerometer, but enough to temporarily disconnect the hotend thermistor giving a def error. I printed this retention clip https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2192079, and used a zip tie, haven't had a problem since. Once I even had a 30-hour print, no problem.

I think I remember the hotend would occasionally lose heat as well, does that sound like the heat fluctuation you mentioned?

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Sun Dec 10, 2017 6:28 pm
by ivanhandler
So, replacing the heated bed worked until now. Last night, tried to start a print. Was going well for about 30 minutes then def appeared. I shut down everything and went to sleep. So now I am trying again. Now the bed just won't heat up. It shows the bed temperature but never changes. I suppose that means I need another hotbed. This is becoming tedious. I wonder if anyone has any clue about why my hot bed would suddenly die. I took it out and inspected everything which looks fine...

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:02 pm
by IMBoring25
Check the heated bed fuse with a multimeter. If that checks bad, replace it. If it checks good, begin standard diagnostics... Voltage at the board, voltage at the bed...

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Mon Dec 11, 2017 7:12 am
by pouncingiguana
Also check the connector on the rambo to make sure it's well tightened down. If it's come loose at all that will cause it to eventually melt down.

Re: def has started to appear frequently destroying prints

Posted: Wed Dec 27, 2017 12:24 pm
by Ducke1963
thank you for all he tips here, i've been having the same problems so i was searching for solutions. i'm also having health problems searching for drug reviews but i guess that's another topic. anyway, thank you once again a lot!